I prefer it how it was before. All increase is worth some risk, as events are too grindy.
I never noticed my XP going up an abnormal amount for the last couple iteration of the mod, it seemed to be right on track to unlock leveled content.
My guess, it was either an issue of leaving the mod on too long, or was a previous bug that people only noticed in the present.
You could always post both versions of the mod (all increase and just gem increase), but my vote is for the all increase if you don't feel like making both.
Thank you for your work! It's very helpful either way!