PMT FREE MOD Harry Potter Hogwarts Mystery Ver. 6.5.2 MOD Menu APK | No Energy, Gem & Coin Costs, Unlock Shop |

[Valmort]

i always found how dumbly is obsessed with DH meanwhile Tom is obsessed with not dying it makes for interesting idea how those 2 act like 2 of brothers in that tail of DH.

How did he know ring has resurrection stone tho?(dumbly obviously)

 

[Pretender Saint]

He can't help it. He has been obsessed with DH since his history with Grindelwald. The DH is their aspirations. Also fueled by his guilt after the tragedy with his sister, Ariana, he wants to use the resurrection stone to bring Ariana back and maybe apologize to her.

Maybe Dumbly asks us to investigate the Gaunt Family ancestry later on. And since we know Elton, it'll be easier to look it up in the ministry extensive archives.

 

[Valmort]

He can't help it. He has been obsessed with DH since his history with Grindelwald. The DH is their aspirations. Also fueled by his guilt after the tragedy with his sister, Ariana, he wants to use the resurrection stone to bring Ariana back and maybe apologize to her.

Maybe Dumbly asks us to investigate the Gaunt Family ancestry later on. And since we know Elton, it'll be easier to look it up in the ministry extensive archives.

I always wondered what would have been if she didnt end up dead in that confict him and his lover had back then(yea i see those two as ex lovers xD).

Isn't there some shit how one we revive with them aren't same as before if we use that stone tho what would be guaranteed he could talk to her normally to begin with and why didn't he use the stone how did stone end up in the golden snitch instead unless he did separate stone and ring).

Also yea i can see dumbly ask us to investigate gaunts as we have easy access to archives making job easier(with the fact that we indeed know elton.)

 

[Pretender Saint]

I always wondered what would have been if she didnt end up dead in that confict him and his lover had back then(yea i see those two as ex lovers xD).

Isn't there some shit how one we revive with them aren't same as before if we use that stone tho what would be guaranteed he could talk to her normally to begin with and why didn't he use the stone how did stone end up in the golden snitch instead unless he did separate stone and ring).

Also yea i can see dumbly ask us to investigate gaunts as we have easy access to archives making job easier(with the fact that we indeed know elton.)

Resurrection Stone can't bring back the dead. It only makes the spirit of the dead appear. Dumbly is feeling guilty af, he longs for a chance to talk to Ariana hence his obsession with the object. Yeah, Dumbly puts the Resurrection Stone in the snitch to be gifted to Harry.

Also yea i can see dumbly ask us to investigate gaunts as we have easy access to archives making job easier(with the fact that we indeed know elton.)

Maybe, it'll be one of the TLSQs in later years lol

 

[icecubic75]

This is why I'm still clinging to this game. I want to be there when Tonks falls in love and when she finds out we know Lupin more earlier than she does.

how I would love a TLSQ about that.

 

[Valmort]

I

Resurrection Stone can't bring back the dead. It only makes the spirit of the dead appear. Dumbly is feeling guilty af, he longs for a chance to talk to Ariana hence his obsession with the object. Yeah, Dumbly puts the Resurrection Stone in the snitch to be gifted to Harry.

So he could technically talk to ariana as spirit still tho? also do we need to think of specific dead person for their spirit to appear i always wondered how it worked beyond this part).

 

[Valmort]

how I would love a TLSQ about that.

lets just hope JC doesn't ban our asses in meantime

 

[Pretender Saint]

how I would love a TLSQ about that.

Haha, just imagine we meet Lupin in the Grimmauld Place and introduce Lupin to Tonks. I mean, we know everyone there except Sirius who's just got out from the Azkaban. Maybe Dumbledore will introduce us to Sirius after the end of Book 3.

 

[Valmort]

Haha, just imagine we meet Lupin in the Grimmauld Place and introduce Lupin to Tonks. I mean, we know everyone there except Sirius who's just got out from the Azkaban. Maybe Dumbledore will introduce us to Sirius after the end of Book 3.

AH the guy he made sure is put in that cursed place just for sake of harry being with petunia and her family....

 

[Pretender Saint]

I

So he could technically talk to ariana as spirit still tho? also do we need to think of specific dead person for their spirit to appear i always wondered how it worked beyond this part).

Yeah, but Ariana might not like it even when she's got to see Dumbly again. It is described that the spirits that are summoned by the stone is 'displeased' by the calling. I think the soul must be whole to be able to be summoned. So, for someone like Voldy's whose soul was mangled, it won't work.

 

[Pretender Saint]

AH the guy he made sure is put in that cursed place just for sake of harry being with petunia and her family....

Wait, who's guy? Sirius??

 

[Valmort]

Yeah, but Ariana might not like it even when she's got to see Dumbly again. It is described that the spirits that are summoned by the stone is 'displeased' by the calling. I think the soul must be whole to be able to be summoned. So, for someone like Voldy's whose soul was mangled, it won't work.

I thought that thing is mostly because you rip them from other side suddenly so they cant stay for long but would ariana jsut scream at him if summoned her due to being dipleased at being before her brother?

 

[icecubic75]

lets just hope JC doesn't ban our asses in meantime

They probably will, and with new MP events, I have a feeling.

 

[Valmort]

Wait, who's guy? Sirius??

i meant sirius yea wasn't he harrys godfather?

 

[Pretender Saint]

i meant sirius yea wasn't he harrys godfather?

I was confused by your previous comment about Harry being with Petunia and her family, because it's actually Dumbly's idea to put Harry in the foster care of Petunia so that Lily's sacrificial love can live inside Harry until he becomes adult.

 

[Valmort]

I was confused by your previous comment about Harry being with Petunia and her family, because it's actually Dumbly's idea to put Harry in the foster care of Petunia so that Lily's sacrificial love can live inside Harry until he becomes adult.

true its shame lilys sisterwas so jelaous of lily she hated magic and her own nephew all over jealousy still what did they actually tell petunia that they would be protected by that sacrifice lily had made?

I imagine they wished harry to be able to be gone away from them despite being their family tbh.

 

[Pretender Saint]

I thought that thing is mostly because you rip them from other side suddenly so they cant stay for long but would ariana jsut scream at him if summoned her due to being dipleased at being before her brother?

Well, not exactly like that. Mostly spirits are displeased because even though they're back to the living world, but they can't be part of the living anymore which could cause them feeling anguish. Just imagine your loved one wish to be with you, but you can do nothing because you both are in different worlds now. In Ariana case, maybe she can bring Dumbly the redemption he always seeks, but I think it'll only worsened his guilt.

 

[Valmort]

Well, not exactly like that. Mostly spirits are displeased because even though they're back to the living world, but they can't be part of the living anymore which could cause them feeling anguish. Just imagine your loved one wish to be with you, but you can do nothing because you both are in different worlds now. In Ariana case, maybe she can bring Dumbly the redemption he always seeks, but I think it'll only worsened his guilt.

Even if he asks her how she died?

 

[Valmort]

Well, not exactly like that. Mostly spirits are displeased because even though they're back to the living world, but they can't be part of the living anymore which could cause them feeling anguish. Just imagine your loved one wish to be with you, but you can do nothing because you both are in different worlds now. In Ariana case, maybe she can bring Dumbly the redemption he always seeks, but I think it'll only worsened his guilt.

So basically they are sad because they cant stay in world where they were summoned in and one that summoned them cant go with them to their side of world due to being still alive?

 

[Pretender Saint]

Even if he asks her how she died?

Even that. But, this is just my speculation. It doesn't matter whose spell was killing Ariana, that scuffle began because of Dumbly's indecisiveness in the first place. His actions led to Ariana's untimely demise, so yeah knowing the truth won't really help at this point. Dumbly needs to learn to let go, that's the point.